Soft Neoprene

For my cell, should I get the soft neoprene rubber or the hard case?
This is it, a basic texting phone:
http://www.handcellphone.com/mobile/files/phone-images/pantech-slate-cell-phone-review-2.jpg
The soft case is by BodyGlove, there is also a hard plastic case. I keep it in my front pants pocket, or rarely in a breast pocket. There is a two-way toggle switch on the side of the phone for navigating.
In your opinion which case is better?
PUt your wallet in your front pocket, yeah that what it’s going to feel like with the hard, So get the rubber this is better it bounces a bit.
Flip Video Neoprene Soft-Pouches – White Line Peeling