Products Seethru Case

Which iPod Touch Case Should I get?
I am either getting this one:
http://www.speckproducts.com/products/seethru-2-pack/ipod-touch-1st-gen/131
in the red/smoke colors
or this one:
http://www.contourcase.com/showcase/showcasetouch/
Please don’t suggest a different case, and it helps if you tell me why i should get one. Thanks.
The first one, because the “hinged design” in the second one just sounds weird, and sounds like 1 more thing to get broken, if dropped.
It also appears like the fist one would provide more protection.
SeeThru Case for MacBook Installation Instructions