Hard Case Sleeve

i have a new macbook pro, what kind of case should i get, a skin, sleeve hard case, which is the best value?
which is the most reliable and best for the value?
Right now I’m looking at 2 hardcover cases for my new MacBook Pro:
1.) Speck SeeThru Satin
These cases come in many colors. However, I have read that it tends to scratch the Mac, and defeats the purpose of getting the case. I’ve also read that it adds a lot of weight, and that makes it less portable.
http://www.speckproducts.com/products/by_device?device_id=65
2.) Incase Hardshell Case
Most of the reviews I’ve read seem to think this is better, but I’m not completely sure why. This doesn’t come in in as many colors. I think that this one is lighter and people seem to think that this does not scratch it. I have also read that this one does not allow you to open the Mac all the way, but I’m not sure if they have changed this or not.
http://www.goincase.com/products/detail/15-hardshell-case-cl57248
I’m currently looking for advice on which one to pick and have a question right now here at Yahoo Answers about it. However, they are both pricey ($50). Yet, I think they would better protect the Mac from scratches and dents than just a sleeve or soft case would.
Hope this helps! We’re both doing the same thing now and I hope we make the best decision!
iPad Bubble Sleeve from Hard Candy (Review)